Top Payroll Services in Cincinnati
Goodfirms has reviewed 7 Payroll Services in Cincinnati as of September 2026. The top-ranked firm is Pay Options (5.0 stars, 1 verified reviews, NA, founded 2011, Cincinnati). Across the category, the median hourly rate is $25, median client rating is 5, and 11% of firms employ 50+ members. Explore the vetted Payroll Services in Cincinnati companies below, compare their strengths, and connect with the provider best suited to your requirements.
In a competitive business environment, it is best for businesses that professional payroll services in Cincinnati take care of their payroll tasks while being focused on their core business functions. Staying in compliance with payroll tax rules and regulations save businesses the hassle of being caught up in avoidable legalities and penalties. Enterprises must have the best experts taking care of your payroll functions by employing the top payroll service providers in Cincinnati. The below list will make it easier to identify the most reputed names in the industry, also helping with a qualitative assessment of each firm. Match the capabilities of the payroll processing companies in Cincinnati with your requirement to hire the best business fit.
Goodfirms has verified 7 Payroll Services in Cincinnati - part of 2,892+ Payroll Services Companies, each passing Goodfirms' 4-step verification process (background check, client interviews, portfolio audit, ongoing quality review). Listings marked "Sponsored" are agencies that pay for premium placement - sponsorship does not affect star ratings or review content.
Top 10 at Glance
Compare the highest-ranked firms first side by side.
List of Top Payroll Service providers in Cincinnati
Sponsored
Experience the difference with a dedicated specialist that knows your account and preferences. Our focus on having the best-in-industry customer service is the backbone of everything we do. We utilize the latest technology couple with one-to-one personal service to automate our clients’ processes and bring ... read Pay Options reviews & insights
NA50 - 2492011Cincinnati, United StatesExcellent payroll provider
- Becky Gmail
For nearly 30 years, Professional Payroll Services, Inc. has been committed to providing the Cincinnati / Tri-State community with the highest level of payroll services available. As a Professional Payroll Services client, you can expect to be assigned a highly trained payroll processor . This processor will be in charge of all aspects of your ... read Professional Payroll Service reviews & insights
NA10 - 491990Cincinnati, United States
Duane Donohoo has been preparing income tax returns beginning in High school at his father’s CPA firm located in Batavia, Ohio. He went to the University of Cincinnati and graduated with a degree in business management. He continued on to receive his bachelor’s degree in Accounting from Northern Kentucky University. On from there he went ... read Donohoo Accounting Services reviews & insights
< $25/hr2 - 91997Cincinnati, United States
We help you simplify the business of life. Spend less time and gain more control over the financial management of your business. It's a snap, using state of the art technology, it's as simple as taking a picture of a receipt... done. Payroll in 2 clicks, it just doesn't get any easier than this. Tax ... read EMC Financial Management Resources LLC reviews & insights
< $25/hr2 - 91983Cincinnati, United States
Our firm is one of the leading firms in the area. By combining our expertise, experience and the energy of our staff, each client receives close personal and professional attention. Our high standards, service and specialized staff spell the difference between our outstanding performance, and other firms. We make sure that every client is served ... read Brauning & Company, LLC reviews & insights
< $25/hr2 - 92010Cincinnati, United States
Sheldon Reder CPAs provides outstanding service to our clients because of our dedication to the three underlying principles of professionalism, responsiveness and quality. We have been ranked in Cincinnati's top 25 largest CPA firms for a number of years running. We combine the quality and resources of a "downtown" firm, while maintaining the personality and ... read Sheldon Reder CPAs reviews & insights
$100 - $149/hr50 - 2491983Cincinnati, United States
Employee Management Services was founded in 1994 and provides professional human resource solutions to more than 160 companies and their 5,500+ employees. We focus our solutions on those companies in Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana, but we are licensed to provide our services in other states. By maintaining this regional focus, we offer an unmatched level ... read Employee Management Services reviews & insights
NA10 - 491994Cincinnati, United States
Post your project. Get proposals from PRO-verified firms.
Goodfirms recommends the top 3. You pick the winner.
Why Trust Goodfirms
Goodfirms is the world’s leading reviews and ratings company featuring 100,000+ tech companies from across the globe, complete with 80,000+ humanly vetted client reviews, detailed portfolios, hourly rates, employee strength, and more to help you choose your perfect tech partner.
Humanly-Vetted Client Reviews
Our researchers have personally vouched for the authenticity of 80,000+ client reviews by speaking directly with clients, cross-checking project details, timelines, and results to ensure 100% credibility.
Data-Driven Rankings
Data powers our company listings. Every company listed is evaluated based on its expertise, experience, market presence, reviews, and client satisfaction rate, which helps buyers confidently choose the right tech partner.
Global Trust & Recognition
Goodfirms is trusted by 100,000+ businesses in 160+ countries to connect with reliable tech partners. Our reputation is built on 80,000+ verified reviews and rankings you can trust.
Transparency In Detail
From verified client reviews and portfolio highlights to service focus and pricing, Goodfirms provides a 360-degree view of every company, helping 2+ million monthly users find the perfect tech partner.
Trending insights from Goodfirms
Valuable insights from top experts accelerate decision-making.
14 Questions Every Fintech Founder Should Ask a BIN Sponsor
Learn the 14 critical questions every fintech founder should ask a BIN sponsor before launching a neobank. Avoid compliance risks, infrastructure failures, and costly migrations.
Business Process Transformation: Strategies, Roadmaps & AI Impact
Discover how to transform business processes through structured roadmaps, collaboration, AI, and continuous improvement for lasting organizational success.
Build High-Performance Teams Through Effective Leadership
Effective leadership helps cultivate high-performing teams by empowering team members, encouraging open communication, skillfully managing talent, and recognizing achievements, enhancing team performance and overall organizational outcomes.
Cincinnati · $0-24/hr