Top Payroll Services in Columbus
Goodfirms has reviewed 9 Payroll Services in Columbus as of September 2026. The top-ranked firm is Doyle HCM (0.0 stars, 0 verified reviews, NA, founded 1990, Columbus). Across the category, the median hourly rate is $37, median client rating is 0, and 23% of firms employ 50+ members. Explore the vetted Payroll Services in Columbus companies below, compare their strengths, and connect with the provider best suited to your requirements.
Consistently changing tax regulations and tax issues make it imperative to find the best payroll services in Columbus that work with complete accountability. Proper filing is desirable while meeting deadlines and ensuring that something as basic as using the latest tax code is followed. All these steps ensure that the business does not get caught up in legalities and is owed to pay penalties that could have been avoided with due diligence. Keeping your business requirements in view, Goodfirms has prepared this list of payroll service providers in Columbus that list the most reputed and dependable firms in the industry. Find all the necessary data with this list required to find the best from payroll processing companies in Columbus for all your needs and wants.
Goodfirms has verified 9 Payroll Services in Columbus - part of 2,892+ Payroll Services Companies, each passing Goodfirms' 4-step verification process (background check, client interviews, portfolio audit, ongoing quality review). Listings marked "Sponsored" are agencies that pay for premium placement - sponsorship does not affect star ratings or review content.
Top 10 at Glance
Compare the highest-ranked firms first side by side.
List of Top Payroll Service providers in Columbus
Sponsored
You need a strategic HR & Payroll partnership that you can trust to watch over the company. Doyle HCM can be that solution. We deliver clients with tailored Human Capital Management strategies and provide administrative relief. We identify challenges quickly and design customized solutions tailored to each client’s specific needs. We become part of your ... read Doyle HCM reviews & insights
NA10 - 491990Columbus, United States
Small Business Payroll Services offers Premium Payroll outsourcing services along with other B2B services. We partner with over 60 companies in the Columbus, Ohio metro area.
NA50 - 2492004Columbus, United States
Formed in 2004 with a desire to offer quality, competitive payroll services, Advanced Payroll Solutions was born from Marino & Company CPA’s clients needing a better solution than the ones they kept running into.With this need and an already seasoned background in accounting and finances, we upgraded our systems, advanced our knowledge and gained more ... read Advanced Payroll Solutions reviews & insights
NA50 - 2492004Columbus, United States
Our firm's reputation for providing quality service reflects the high standards we demand of ourselves. Our high standards, responsive service and specialized staff spell the difference between our firm and the rest.
NA50 - 2491988Columbus, United States
We are a team of accounting and business advisory professionals who help companies grow through thoughtful, personalized service. We model a business approach that confirms that problem-solving people – and not the numbers themselves – are true drivers of long-term success. As a CPA firm in Columbus Ohio with a diversified client base, we offer ... read Holbrook & Manter, CPAs reviews & insights
$50 - $99/hr50 - 2491919Columbus, United States
We try to meet your needs in the most practical and cost effective manner. If our strengths, experience or personalities are not a good fit, we will bring in other reliable parties to help meet the need, or refer you to another reputable firm. Our fees are fair, but not the lowest — you get ... read Neilley & Co. reviews & insights
$25 - $49/hr2 - 91998Columbus, United States
HarQuin Bookkeeping and Consulting Services is locally owned and operated business in Central Ohio. We pride ourselves on providing affordable, quality bookkeeping and consulting services. We enjoy assisting small business owners achieve their goals and dreams for themselves and their families. We always welcome the opportunity to sit down and discuss the future of your ... read HarQuin Bookkeeping and Consulting Services reviews & insights
$25 - $49/hr10 - 492008Columbus, United States
Through innovative technology and our knowledgeable staff, we provide solutions to streamline business development and maintenance in the areas of Payroll, Time & Attendance, Human Resources, and Employee Benefits. For the last 33 years we have served our clients with the most efficient pathways for lowering cost and building efficiency. Let us serve your needs ... read HR Butler reviews & insights
NA50 - 2491984Columbus, United States
CPA Advisory Group, Inc. is a full-service CPA firm in Westerville, Ohio. We specialize in servicing the needs of small businesses and individuals, adding value to our clients' experience through creative approaches to help you not only survive, but flourish in these turbulent economic times.
$50 - $99/hr10 - 491985Columbus, United States
Post your project. Get proposals from PRO-verified firms.
Goodfirms recommends the top 3. You pick the winner.
Why Trust Goodfirms
Goodfirms is the world’s leading reviews and ratings company featuring 100,000+ tech companies from across the globe, complete with 80,000+ humanly vetted client reviews, detailed portfolios, hourly rates, employee strength, and more to help you choose your perfect tech partner.
Humanly-Vetted Client Reviews
Our researchers have personally vouched for the authenticity of 80,000+ client reviews by speaking directly with clients, cross-checking project details, timelines, and results to ensure 100% credibility.
Data-Driven Rankings
Data powers our company listings. Every company listed is evaluated based on its expertise, experience, market presence, reviews, and client satisfaction rate, which helps buyers confidently choose the right tech partner.
Global Trust & Recognition
Goodfirms is trusted by 100,000+ businesses in 160+ countries to connect with reliable tech partners. Our reputation is built on 80,000+ verified reviews and rankings you can trust.
Transparency In Detail
From verified client reviews and portfolio highlights to service focus and pricing, Goodfirms provides a 360-degree view of every company, helping 2+ million monthly users find the perfect tech partner.
Trending insights from Goodfirms
Valuable insights from top experts accelerate decision-making.
14 Questions Every Fintech Founder Should Ask a BIN Sponsor
Learn the 14 critical questions every fintech founder should ask a BIN sponsor before launching a neobank. Avoid compliance risks, infrastructure failures, and costly migrations.
Business Process Transformation: Strategies, Roadmaps & AI Impact
Discover how to transform business processes through structured roadmaps, collaboration, AI, and continuous improvement for lasting organizational success.
Build High-Performance Teams Through Effective Leadership
Effective leadership helps cultivate high-performing teams by empowering team members, encouraging open communication, skillfully managing talent, and recognizing achievements, enhancing team performance and overall organizational outcomes.
Columbus · $0-24/hr