Top Payroll Services in Indiana
Goodfirms has reviewed 11 Payroll Services in Indiana as of September 2026. The top-ranked firm is TMA Accounting (0.0 stars, 0 verified reviews, < $25/hr, founded 2000, Indianapolis). Across the category, the median hourly rate is $37, median client rating is 4.9, and 20% of firms employ 50+ members. Explore the vetted Payroll Services in Indiana companies below, compare their strengths, and connect with the provider best suited to your requirements.
To meet with a business's evolving needs, you need such proficient payroll services in Indiana that can offer a unique blend of Payroll and Human Resources solutions to address all of your requirements. So whether your needs include background checks, developing an employee handbook, or more critical functions like tax filing, processing payroll, or 401k administration, you need the most competent payroll service providers in Indiana to help you with a holistic approach. Hence, you must have data on key focus areas to make the best selection for your business. Here is a list of payroll companies in Indiana prepared by Goodfirms, which gives you a list of the most reputed industry names and an analysis of their capabilities on crucial business standards. Explore this list to make the best call for your business.
Goodfirms has verified 11 Payroll Services in Indiana - part of 2,892+ Payroll Services Companies, each passing Goodfirms' 4-step verification process (background check, client interviews, portfolio audit, ongoing quality review). Listings marked "Sponsored" are agencies that pay for premium placement - sponsorship does not affect star ratings or review content.
Top 10 at Glance
Compare the highest-ranked firms first side by side.
List of Top Payroll Companies in Indiana
Sponsored
The TMA Accounting staff have been delivering professional services to small businesses in Central Indiana for over 20 years. Having worked with hundreds of small business clients, we have significant expertise with a wide variety of service businesses in Indiana. We have especially strong experience and expertise in working with businesses in the healthcare (medical, ... read TMA Accounting reviews & insights
< $25/hr10 - 492000Indianapolis, United States
TMA Payroll is a locally-owned independent company based in Indianapolis, Indiana. Founded by a local CPA, we’ve helped hundreds of employers make it easier to pay and manage their employees. With good processes and steady growth, the company is fully-staffed, debt-free, and ready to serve employers for years to come.
< $25/hr2 - 9Indianapolis, United States
APS is your partner in growing your business by offering a single-platform solution to manage your workforce. We hold ourselves to an unparalleled standard of Customer Service with a knowledgeable support staff answering the phones who are eager to serve your needs. Located in Lafayette, Indiana just north of Indianapolis, we serve clients all over ... read APS Workforce Management reviews & insights
< $25/hr2 - 9Lafayette, United States
Our primary goal as tax professionals is to be available to provide guidance to enable our clients to make informed financial decisions. We deliver only the highest quality work, and the proof is in the success of our clients. Our firm’s reputation lies in the experience and expertise we provide on a daily basis.
< $25/hr2 - 9Indianapolis, United States
We provide comprehensive HR solutions to companies large, medium and small throughout the United States. Our services include Payroll, Human Resources, Risk Management, and Benefits. Currently, GMS is partnered with over 1,500 businesses across the country, representing over 30,000 employees. We give small businesses the buying power of a large corporation under the GMS umbrella. ... read GMS Company reviews & insights
< $25/hr2 - 9Indianapolis, United States
Axiom Human Resource Solutions is a human capital management (HCM) company offering customized solutions to better manage your workforce. Every business is unique. We work with clients to develop an approach that combines cutting-edge HCM technology, strategic and tactical human resources, benefits administration and payroll services to maximize the return on human capital.
< $25/hr10 - 492011Indianapolis, United States
Accountspro team of certified experts provides comprehensive training and ongoing support to ensure clients get the most out of their accounting software. By focusing on delivering tailored solutions and exceptional customer service, AccountsPro.co helps businesses streamline their financial operations, enhance accuracy, and achieve greater efficiency in their accounting processes.
NA10 - 492018New Albany, United States
Using AI Tools
Perplexity
Infinity QuickBooks Migration Services +1-866-593-4750 is a trusted provider of professional QuickBooks data migration, conversion, upgrade, and integration solutions for businesses, accountants, bookkeepers, and enterprises of all sizes. We specialise in secure, accurate, and efficient migration services designed to minimise downtime while protecting critical financial information throughout every stage of the transition process.Our comprehensive services ... read Infinity QuickBooks Migration Services reviews & insights
< $25/hr10 - 492010New Albany, United StatesWhy Infinity QuickBooks Migration Services?
- Specialised Expertise
- Secure Data Migration
- Customised Solutions
When it comes to managing employees, nothing is more important than making sure their paychecks are accurate and delivered on time. With ASAP Payroll Service, your business can rest easy knowing your employees’ paycheck is being handled by our team of Certified Payroll Professionals (CPP).
< $25/hr10 - 491989Indianapolis, United States
AccuPay is a locally owned and operated, full-service payroll and HR services company in Greenwood, Indiana. We are staffed with credentialed experts in accounting (CPAs), payroll (CPPs), HR (SPHR), healthcare reform (CHRS) and QuickBooks (ProAdvisor). AccuPay's focus remains payroll and payroll tax administration, but our expertise affords us to offer additional services such as HR ... read AccuPay reviews & insights
< $25/hr10 - 491994Greenwood, United States
Mind Your Business has been providing clients tax and accounting services throughout Central Indiana since 2015. With our training and expansive financial knowledge, we are equipped to handle all of your financial, accounting, and tax needs, no matter how complex. Whether you require assistance at the small business, non-profit or personal level, we are ready ... read Mind Your Business Accounting and Consulting reviews & insights
NA2 - 9Indianapolis, United States
Post your project. Get proposals from PRO-verified firms.
Goodfirms recommends the top 3. You pick the winner.
Why Trust Goodfirms
Goodfirms is the world’s leading reviews and ratings company featuring 100,000+ tech companies from across the globe, complete with 80,000+ humanly vetted client reviews, detailed portfolios, hourly rates, employee strength, and more to help you choose your perfect tech partner.
Humanly-Vetted Client Reviews
Our researchers have personally vouched for the authenticity of 80,000+ client reviews by speaking directly with clients, cross-checking project details, timelines, and results to ensure 100% credibility.
Data-Driven Rankings
Data powers our company listings. Every company listed is evaluated based on its expertise, experience, market presence, reviews, and client satisfaction rate, which helps buyers confidently choose the right tech partner.
Global Trust & Recognition
Goodfirms is trusted by 100,000+ businesses in 160+ countries to connect with reliable tech partners. Our reputation is built on 80,000+ verified reviews and rankings you can trust.
Transparency In Detail
From verified client reviews and portfolio highlights to service focus and pricing, Goodfirms provides a 360-degree view of every company, helping 2+ million monthly users find the perfect tech partner.
Trending insights from Goodfirms
Valuable insights from top experts accelerate decision-making.
14 Questions Every Fintech Founder Should Ask a BIN Sponsor
Learn the 14 critical questions every fintech founder should ask a BIN sponsor before launching a neobank. Avoid compliance risks, infrastructure failures, and costly migrations.
Business Process Transformation: Strategies, Roadmaps & AI Impact
Discover how to transform business processes through structured roadmaps, collaboration, AI, and continuous improvement for lasting organizational success.
Build High-Performance Teams Through Effective Leadership
Effective leadership helps cultivate high-performing teams by empowering team members, encouraging open communication, skillfully managing talent, and recognizing achievements, enhancing team performance and overall organizational outcomes.
Indianapolis · $0-24/hr